The ButcherBox Growth Story: How to Make Early Adopters Your Secret Weapon with Juan Camilo Meisel

Jared Mintzlaff

January 10, 2024

We’re thrilled to share our biggest takeaways from an enlightening conversation with Juan Meisel, former Marketer and Head of Logistics at ButcherBox, and current Founder & CEO of Grip.

When Juan Meisel and his scrappy team first launched ButcherBox, the prospects seemed dim. Selling subscriptions for premium frozen meat nationwide in 2015 was still uncharted territory.

But the team remained fueled by a counterintuitive insight — that their fledgling community of early adopters could be their secret growth weapon. By embedding customers into each step of the process through unprecedented transparency and collaboration, ButcherBox transformed users from passive purchasers to vocal partners.

This cycle of constant co-creation unlocked game-changing innovations, while forging an invaluable tribe of brand devotees. Soon what began as a “random startup”morphed into one of the renowned pioneers of the direct-to-consumer (D2C) movement.

Juan gave us an insider’s view into how ButcherBox succeeded. Here were my favorite tactics Juan shared that you can steal. But first, check out the full interview here:

Start With First Principles

The ButcherBox genesis began by fixating on user struggles instead of marketing tactics. Juan recalls:

“For us, the early days were always about how can we get people to buy frozen meat online? Like, forget about ButcherBox. How can we get people to understand that they can go online, they can hit purchase, and a box of frozen meat shows up at their doorstep?”

Rather than making grand assumptions about consumer interests, they returned to first principles - what underserved needs could they meet through meat subscriptions?

As you ponder new offerings, resist the temptation to hypothesize customer problems. directly engage your audience to expose their deepest frustrations. Use surveys, interviews and community polls to spotlight struggles they’ll eagerly pay to resolve.

Co-Design with Power Users

With core user issues identified, ButcherBox doubled down on its tribe of early adopters to pioneer solutions. Juan recalls:

“We work with what we call fast innovation cycles, which means that we go from idea to product to feedback very fast. But we have the customer in the middle of that equation. So in every single stage of this triangle, we speak with the customer and we make sure that we're developing the product with them and not for them.”

Avoid siloed product teams who disappear for months before presenting finished solutions. Identify your most engaged power users and embed them into rapid build-measure-learn sprint cycles.

Map the user journey to detect friction points. Brainstorm solutions collaboratively. And develop minimum viable products (MVPs) to quickly gather real-world feedback. By truly partnering with users, you’ll organically evolve offerings that seamlessly resolve their struggles.

Invest in Ongoing Dialogue

But ButcherBox didn’t stop at periodic check-ins. They nurtured ongoing two-way conversations to cement intimate customer connections. Here’s one initiative Juan introduced:

“We had a goal that every single company member had to speak with at least five customers very regularly...”

Build organization-wide rituals that nurture dialogue through regular user touch-points at all levels. Setup live calls, chat support and community forums. Set quotas for direct outreach from executives to users.

Track feedback meticulously to catch emerging opportunities. And implement cricket teams to rapidly test and enhance offerings based on intel. Soon you’ll be organically delivering extreme value far beyond competitors.

Make Them Heroes of Your Origin Story

ButcherBox struck gold by publicly spotlighting how users courageously joined them in pioneering uncharted territory. Early supporters literally made the brand possible through volunteering data, feedback and referrals.

Juan suggests subtly spotlighting how customers contributed to key innovations:

“The long-term customers saw a full evolution of the packaging. We went through at least seven or nine types of different materials and packaging, and all of it was done because we had the customers and the volume.”

Edit origin stories across channels to highlight user partnership at pivotal moments. Spotlight how feedback or data from initial fans inspired new offerings. And showcase customers who passionately spread the word when no one else understood your moxie vision.

This nurtures a “Comrades in Arms” positioning where users feel like revered insiders vs passive shoppers. Eventually this cultivates irrational loyalty even among newly acquired fans who missed the early days.

Keep Evolving the Relationship

While rich user insights catalyzed early traction, ButcherBox refuses to rest on its laurels.

Avoid stagnating into one-way transactions. Continue engaging fans with unexpected value and privileged access. Seek honest feedback on underserved needs and evolving preferences.

Surprise and delight through unique experiences and personalization. And stay eager to not just meet demands, but uplift lives beyond the purchase. Eventually your brand becomes not just a convenience, but a cherished community.

The road from fledgling startup to household name wasn’t smooth for ButcherBox. But by wholeheartedly embracing customers as partners instead of passive purchasers, they uncovered a secret growth catalyst their rivals overlooked.

Now you can replicate their playbook. By forging authentic user intimacy since day one, you’ll not only earn devotees - but collaborators who ensure your solution always stays two steps ahead.

See Nifty Bridge in action

Find out how experience led loyalty can supercharge you brand's growth
Contact Us